Domestic Violence: Power Issue vs Gender Issue
Tuesday, October 16 2012 Kellie Jo Holly
When it comes to the statistics about domestic abuse, it doesn't matter to me how many men to how many women experience domestic violence. Domestic violence is a power issue more than a gender issue. Intimate Partner Violence affects men and women, and I really do not care in what proportion.
Domestic violence will not end until
- no person seeks power over another person, or
- every person learns to recognize the tactics of control and manipulation early in a relationship so they can make the decision to get out before the abuser hurts them (more).
I do not see the day when no person seeks power over another. I believe the majority of people want and work for equitable relationships, but I also believe there will always be those who do not. I think the desire for power over another person is a temptation all of us battle with at times. Some of us win that battle, and some of us lose ourselves in it.
Victim or Survivor? The Choice is Yours
In the absence of our ability to make people stop abusing, we're left with the option of personal responsibility. It is up to each of us to decide that no one is allowed to hurt us emotionally, mentally or physically. If they do hurt us, it is up to us to end the abuse. No one else can do that for us. There are helping agencies designed to educate and support us, but ultimately, the decision to remain with an abusive person and find ways to deal with the abuse or to leave the relationship is our responsibility. Any abused male or female has the same choice - it is no different for either gender.
There is no doubt that our court system does not have the means to appropriately deal with non-physical abuse when it comes to the end of relationships and in regards to custody. In fact, the family court system often fails to protect the children when it comes to physically violent parents, awarding custody or allowing inappropriate visitations to the abuser. The family court system is a serious problem that cannot be avoided when victims of abuse with children choose to end the relationship. The court's decisions are often unfair to the victim and to the children.
How you choose to handle the consequences imposed by the court is your decision. You can decide that you are a victim and compound your problems, or you can decide that you will survive the court's decision with valor and commitment until the day comes when you have more evidence to refute it. Any male or female has the same choice - it is no different for either gender.
Whether you stay or leave an abusive relationship, you will also face the abuser's continued ability to say whatever they want to say about you. You may lose friends. You could lose your job. Your abuser could stalk and harass you. You could find yourself more isolated after the abuse than you were during it, especially as the agencies that aided your escape lose interest in you now that you're free. You can choose to feel victimized, or you choose to survive: find new friends, utilize other helping agencies to find work, do what you must to protect yourself from stalking, and reach out to end your isolation in healthy ways. Can you guess what I'm about to say? The choice is no different whether you're male or female.
Why I'm So Bent About Gender
Within anti-domestic violence advocacy, there seems to be a trend to pit female victims against male victims and vice-verse. I do not know who is behind it, nor do I know if there is a "who" to blame. I do know that blame has no place in this fight against domestic abuse, especially when victim blames victim for any reason.
I hate it that some men find government support lacking or completely unavailable. This is a gender issue because its roots are in the belief that women cannot abuse men and any man who accepted abuse for any length of time isn't a man worth protecting. I hate it that some women do not fare well in family court because some people think they "cry abuse" when all else fails. This is a gender issue because its roots are in the question "Why would she stay if it was so bad?" and ignores the very real prejudices women continue to face in our country.
I also cannot stand the new trending belief that both parents are better than one parent even with evidence that one of the parents abuse because it is a corruption of the Father's Rights movement. This is a complicated issue that I believe resulted from the pendulum swinging too quickly for societal acceptance in women's needed and just quest for equality. I have issues with including domestic violence in the Violence Against Women Act because its title perpetrates the myth that only males abuse and that females are weaker and need Big Brother's separate and unique protection.
In a perfect society, men and women are equally protected under the law not because more laws were made to protect one sex but because in each mind and heart of all people, women and men are respected equally, and their individual contributions or crimes are our only measures of judgment. However, this ideal is as far away from our current reality as the idea that no person would seek power over another.
Until everyone is considered equal and no one desires power over another, it is left to each of us, individually, to choose to be a victim or a survivor. Survivors fight against inequality and wrongful judgment (the essence of abuse) in whatever way they deem fit, proper and true. Victims stop trying. It does not matter how many injustices you endure or what gender you happen to be - the choice to be a victim or a survivor is yours and yours alone.