Michael Matthews

SHOCKED! ECT

Home
About Me
Effects of ECT
ECT News
Hall of Shame
Personal ECT Stories
Forced Electroshock
Trends in ECT
Studies, Statistics, Reports
Self-Help / Alt. Depression Treatment
ECT Bulletin Board

back to
depression community

send this page to a friend

News Alert

http://www.MindFreedom.org NEWS ALERT #9
YOU Can Help Win Human Rights in Mental Health
Please redistribute. To unsubscribe see bottom.

Friday, March 8, 2002 - HUMAN RIGHTS ACTION ALERT

IT'S FRIDAY: A SEVENTY-ONE-YEAR-OLD MAN IS BEING
ELECTROSHOCKED **RIGHT NOW** AGAINST HIS WILL
IN RIVERVIEW HOSPITAL IN VANCOUVER, CANADA

HE RECEIVES FORCED ELECTROSHOCK *EVERY* FRIDAY

ACTION: YOU CAN E-MAIL THE HOSPITAL CEO TO
FIGHT FOR MICHAEL MATTHEW'S HUMAN RIGHTS!

by Juli Lawrence, director, http://ECT.ORG

VANCOUVER, CANADA: Every Friday, Michael Matthews, a 71-year-old patient at Riverview Hospital in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada receives an electroshock treatment against his will.

He has continued to tell human rights activists that he does not want the treatments, yet he has received more than 70, according to a hospital insider who asked not to be named.

"He used to be a delightful conversationalist with a good attention span," says the insider. "He had the sweetest disposition -- something everyone commented on and appreciated. We all loved chatting with Michael. Gradually he has become more and more agitated, irritable, confused, and delusional."

Vancouver activist Julie Butler recently met with Michael, and said that he was suffering from the typical effects of electroshock.

"He is suffering from the classic documented side effects of the treatment which include long and short term memory loss, confusion, and disorientation," says Butler. "When I first met Michael, burns and bruises were evident on his temples, which would also seem to be from the continued and excessive use of this treatment."

Riverview Hospital was the center of a governmental investigation last year when staff psychiatrist Jaime Paredes
contacted Minister of Health Corky Evans with concerns over the increased use of electroshock after the Ministry increased payments to doctors.

"The number of ECT treatments in the Geriatric Psychiatry Program at Riverview Hospital has more than doubled since fee-for-service was introduced," wrote Dr. Paredes. "I feel the machinery and wheels of bureaucracy are slowly grinding this matter into obscurity. But it is real people who are affected, patients with no power and with no voice."

Paredes, who worked at Riverview 15 years, was fired in December and has said he believes his firing was a result of speaking out. He said a colleague who supported him was also fired, and another was demoted. Riverview administrators have denied that the firings were related to the controversy and resulting investigation.

Activists have attempted to visit Michael again, but have been refused entry by hospital officials.

The hospital insider says that Michael views the electroshock treatments as punishment.

"They're trying to get rid of me. They think I'm a problem," the insider reports Michael saying.

The insider adds: "Michael talks to the walls now, falls asleep in the middle of sentences, tells us he is probably Jesus Christ, and rambles on endlessly in total nonsense. It just breaks my heart."

"Electroshocking elderly people, particularly women, is ageist, sexist and elder abuse," says Don Weitz of Toronto, author of the article "Electroshocking Elderly People -- Another Psychiatric Abuse."

"Shocking old and physically fragile people without informed consent is increasing at an alarming rate in both the United States and Canada -- particularly in Ontario and British Columbia -- as well as the UK and probably other European countries," Weitz said. "In Ontario during the year 1999-2000, over 2,500 people were forcibly subjected to over 15,000 shocks."

ECT practitioners continue to say that ECT is a very safe and effective treatment, despite the well-known high relapse rate and extensive side effects. In a study published in the _Journal of the American Medical Association_ last year showed that ECT is so ineffective at relieving depression, that nearly all of 290 patients relapsed within six months.

"Since the shock doctors and other psychiatrists routinely violate the legal right to informed consent, virtually all shock is forced. I accuse the shock doctors in particular and psychiatry in general with causing great harm, intentionally misinforming or lying to their patients and the public about permanent memory loss and brain damage, violating medical ethics, and perpetrating a crime against humanity," added Weitz.

Calls to administrators and the head of geriatric psychiatry at Riverview were not returned.

ACTION *** ACTION *** ACTION

Here is an easy way you can help now:

Email, call and/or fax these Riverview Hospital staff, a sample message is below.

Marion Suski, Chief Executive Officer
email: msuski@bcmhs.bc.ca
fax: 604-524-7016

Dr. Arlind Kang, Medical Director, Geriatric Psychiatry Program
email: akang@bcmhs.bc.ca

Alastair Gordon, Director of Community Relations
email: agordon@bcmhs.bc.ca
phone 604-524-7378
fax: 604-524-7016

Please keep your message civil.

Please COPY your message to: Juli@ect.org

SAMPLE E-MAIL MESSAGE TO HOSPITAL STAFF --
use this or put in your own words:

To: msuski@bcmhs.bc.ca, akang@bcmhs.bc.ca, agordon@bcmhs.bc.ca
Copy: Juli@ect.org

Stop forced electroshock in Riverview Hospital! Stop the forced electroshock of Michael Matthews! Michael has repeatedly stated he does not wish to have electroshock! I request an immediate response.

Optional: Include your name, address, phone, e-mail.

ADDITIONAL ACTIONS *** ADDITIONAL ACTIONS

Governmental Contacts:

Honorable Colin Hansen, Minister of Health Services
email: HLTH.Health@gems1.gov.bc.ca
fax: 250-356-9587

Honorable Dr. Gulzar Cheema, Minister of Mental Health
email: gulzar.cheema@gems4.gov.bc.ca
fax: 250-356-8264

Katherine Whittred
Minister of State for Intermediate, Longterm & Homecare
email: katherine.whittred@gems6.gov.bc.ca
fax: 250-356-8264

Gordon Campbell, Premier
fax: 250-387-0087
email: premier@gov.bc.ca

Media Contacts:

CBC - The Fifth Estate
email: fifth@toronto.cbc.ca
fax: (416) 205-6668
phone: (416) 205-6663

Vancouver Sun
email globalbc.newstips@globaltv.ca
fax: 604-421-9427
phone: 604-420-2288

For your convenience, here are all the e-mail addresses
listed above for the hospital, government and media:

msuski@bcmhs.bc.ca, akang@bcmhs.bc.ca, agordon@bcmhs.bc.ca,
HLTH.Health@gems1.gov.bc.ca, gulzar.cheema@gems4.gov.bc.ca
katherine.whittred@gems6.gov.bc.ca, premier@gov.bc.ca
fifth@toronto.cbc.ca, globalbc.newstips@globaltv.ca

copy: Juli@ect.org

This human rights alert was prepared by
Juli Lawrence, director of http://ECT.ORG, one
of 100 sponsor groups in Support Coalition
International. For info e-mail to: Juli@ect.org

For news & photos of other recent Support Coalition
International campaigns against forced electroshock see:
http://www.mindfreedom.org/mindfreedom/paul.shtml

PLEASE COPY & POST THIS HUMAN RIGHTS ALERT TO ALL APPROPRIATE PLACES ON AND OFF THE INTERNET.

http://www.MindFreedom.org NEWS ALERT #9 is a free public service sent to several thousand people internationally who take ACTION for human rights.

Support Coalition International is a totally independent non-profit federation of about 100 grassroots groups united to win human rights and alternatives in the "mental health system." SCI receives no funding from the psychiatric drug industry, the "mental health system" or the government. You are invited to join.

You can join, donate and renew your membership with Support Coalition International by VISA, MasterCard, Discover & American Express via a secure web server: http://mindfreedom.org/join.shtml.

Build strength in numbers. And members get 10 percent off more than 75 items in the MAD MARKET: http://www.mindfreedom.org/madmarket/

To receive www.MindFreedom.org NEWS ALERTS: These alerts are occasional so you do not get too much e-mail. E-mail to ListProc@efn.org with these two words only in body of message:

subscribe dendrite

Or sign up for alerts automatically on the web at:
http://www.mindfreedom.org/alerts.shtml

To stop receiving these human rights news alerts,
e-mail to ListProc@efn.org with these two words
only in the body of your message:

unsubscribe dendrite

If you continue to receive alerts, you may have more than one e-mail address or there may be another problem. Please forward the alert you received by error with a request to leave the list to office@mindfreedom.org.

Background info on this story:
Canadian Province Calls for Investigation
Vancouver - The province has ordered an independent investigation to determine why electroshock treatments administered to geriatric patients at British Columbia's major psychiatric hospital have more than doubled since doctors began to be paid extra for the procedure. Insider speaks out!

Extra! Outspoken doctor RESIGNS: "My professional and personal concerns have come from the heart," says Dr. Jaime Paredes. "In response, my questions have been met with indifference and defensiveness from certain quarters."

The final report. Among the recommendations: start keeping statistics.

More on the Riverview scandal: A psychiatrist at Riverview Hospital says he has been fired for blowing the whistle on "greedy" colleagues and trying to protect elderly patients. Dr. Jaime Paredes, who alleged last year that some doctors at the institution were performing needless electro-shock therapy to plump their bank accounts, said he was told a week ago his contract was being terminated.

top | sitemap | send page to a friend

HealthyPlace.com Depression Center Links
home ~ site map

HealthyPlace.com Homepage
Chat ~ Forums ~ Communities
HealthyPlace.com Films ~ HealthyPlace.com Radio ~ News
Site Map ~ Web Tour ~ Advertise ~ Email Us
send this page to a friend

We subscribe to the HONcode principles of the Health On the Net Foundation.