• advertisement

Our Mental Health Blogs

Mentally Ill and the Death Penalty – Fate of Scott Panetti

Mentally Ill and the Death Penalty – Fate of Scott Panetti

Navy veteran, Scott Panetti, was diagnosed with schizophrenia in 1978 and hospitalized 14 times for the disorder. In 1992, he suffered a psychotic break and killed his wife’s parents, telling the police that “Sarge” did it and demons were laughing at him. Amazingly, he was allowed to represent himself, and passed up a plea deal that would have saved his life. At his trial, he wore a cowboy suit, subpoenaed Jesus Christ, the Pope and President Kennedy, and argued that only an insane person could prove the insanity defense. He was sentenced to death.

Continue reading

Closure of Mental Health Court Makes Everyone A Loser

Closure of Mental Health Court Makes Everyone A Loser

Recently I was at Three Carrots vegan restaurant in Indianapolis City Market when I struck up a conversation with a prosecutor. I mentioned the city’s mental health court, and she told me it no longer exists. It was phased out after the judge retired. When I expressed my concern, she said she was sympathetic. “I’ve got a guy right now who needs to be in mental health court. We can’t let him go because he has nowhere to live, he needs treatment, and we can’t keep him in jail forever . . .” She shook her head, and we both agreed it was sad that the leading provider for mental health services is the Marion County Jail.

Continue reading

Should Psychiatric Patients Have the Right to See Their Files?

Should Psychiatric Patients Have the Right to See Their Files?

My diagnosis varies, depending on who you believe. I remember one nurse practitioner told me I was too meditative and introverted and must have narcissistic personality disorder–no one backed up that “diagnosis,” but it’s in my file. I’d love to be able to get it removed. But as a borderline personality disorder patient, I have no right to see my file without my psychiatrist’s permission. The same applies to past practitioners’ notes. Which leads to an interesting question–should psychiatric patients have the right to see their file?

Continue reading

When a Person with Mental Illness Witnesses a Crime

When a Person with Mental Illness Witnesses a Crime

I live in a bad neighborhood, complete with an abandoned house next door. About a week ago, I saw a man with a crowbar and a bag enter the house through the previously boarded-up window. I called 911 to report a breaking and entering (B and E), and the police came out to investigate.

Or so I thought.

I walked outside, identified myself as the caller and prepared to positively identify the suspect. However, the police just looked at the forced-open window and left without saying a word. They didn’t even interview me. I later learned that it’s not the first time this guy has had the cops called on him–my landlord has called the police, but nothing has been done.

The whole experience has caused my symptoms of borderline personality disorder (BPD) to flare up. It has made me think about what a person with mental illness can do when they witness, or, God forbid, are victims of, a crime.

Continue reading

What the Hobby Lobby Decision Means for People with Mental Illness

What the Hobby Lobby Decision Means for People with Mental Illness

The Supreme Court ruled 5-4 in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby that an employer does not need to cover contraceptives if it conflicts with a sincerely held religious belief. Some are saying it’s a victory for religions liberty, others say it’s a startling setback for women. The truth is probably somewhere in the middle. But this is a column about mental illness, and what the recent decision means for mental health consumers. In short, we’re in danger.

Continue reading

Is Locking Up People with Borderline the Answer?

Is Locking Up People with Borderline the Answer?

Sadly, one of my previous posts can be recycled. I wrote about whether or not people with severe mental illnesses should have firearm rights after the events in Aurora, Colorado (Should People with a Mental Illness Have Firearm Rights). Now there’s been another killing spree in which mental illness may have been a factor. I would not be surprised if Elliot Rodger had a diagnosis of borderline personality disorder (BPD)–his difficulty in relationships and inappropriate anger are two symptoms of the disorder. It raises the question, “Is locking up people with borderline the answer?”

Continue reading

Can We Forgive When There Is No Justice?

Can We Forgive When There Is No Justice?

As a sexual assault survivor, I have an interest in cases of rape that make the news. Recently, here in Indianapolis, a man was convicted of several sex offenses, including rape. But there was no justice–the male judge looked at the victim and told her she had to forgive her attacker and move on, then sentenced her rapist to eight years of house arrest.

That judge has no idea what he asked her to do. But it raises an important question: Can we forgive when there is no justice?

Continue reading

When People with Mental Illness Become Prey

When People with Mental Illness Become Prey

There’s a rumor going around that my payee was fired because he was pocketing the money from his clients’ Social Security checks. The results have not been pretty. Trust between staff and clients is on the skids, and people are borderline paranoid of losing more money. When someone asked, “Why do they take advantage of mentally ill people like that?”, my friend Michael replied, “Because they can.” It made me think about what happens when people with mental illness have encounters with the criminal justice system.

Continue reading

When the Court Makes It Worse For People With Mental Illness

When the Court Makes It Worse For People With Mental Illness

The rights of people with mental illness are a developing field. Sometimes court decisions have made things better than us–for example, the law that if in crisis, only the least restrictive means can be used to restrain us. Sometimes, however, court decisions have made things worse. What is in our best interests is not always what the court has ruled is right.

Continue reading

Handling Violence in Mental Illness Treatment Facilities

Handling Violence in Mental Illness Treatment Facilities

Violence in mental illness treatment facilities needs to be punished. How should we deal with a person with treatment? Here are three questions we should ask.

On a normal day, I could have walked away.

Very few of my neighbors in this mental illness treatment facility are violent. That said, one of my neighbors, who has a history of aggression, recently started cussing me out with a mix of b-words and f-bombs, then challenged me to a fistfight. I took off my glasses and said I was fine with that as long as she threw the first punch. She told me “”#$%!, you throw the first punch, I ain’t crazy!” and a social worker came and broke it up.

I went to my apartment and immediately had an asthma attack (Physical Disorders with Panic-Like Symptoms). I also punched a wall, bruising three knuckles. Not my finest moment, and not normal for me. But afterwards, I thought about what should happen when violence in mental illness treatment facilities becomes a problem.

Continue reading


Follow Us

  • advertisement

in More Than Borderline Comments

Mental Health Newsletter

Sign up for the HealthyPlace mental health newsletter for latest news, articles, events.

Mental Health
Newsletter Subscribe Now!

Mental Health Newsletter

Sign up for the HealthyPlace mental health newsletter for latest news, articles, events.

Log in

Login to your account

Username *
Password *
Remember Me