Relationships Between Men's and
Women's Body Image and Their Psychological, Social, and Sexual Functioning
continued from
HealthyPlace.com Audio
Boys
and Body Image
The
pressures on girls to be thin are well known, but do boys
feel the pressure too when it comes to shaping up?
Listen with
Real Player.
The
Adonis Complex
From
GI Joe to pro wrestling, to magazines to movies, everywhere
we look, we see muscular, fit men. Millions of men and boys
are feeling pressured to achieve the impossible goal of
physical perfection. Men are spending countless hours in the
gym, young boys are taking food supplements and diet aids,
and many are using dangerous anabolic steroids and black
market equivalents to push the limits of their physiques.
More and more men are suffering from eating disorders; a
recent study found that 40% of Americans who go on
compulsive eating sprees are men. Our guests are Dr. Michael
J. Pertschuck, the medical director of the eating disorders
program at Friends Hospital and Dr. Harrison G. Pope, one of
the authors of "The Adonis Complex: The Secret Crisis of
Male Body Obsession"
Listen with
Real Player.
|
|
|
This research has demonstrated the importance of considering
multiple measures of body image, given that different measures were
associated with different aspects of psychological, social, and sexual
functioning. Social aspects of body image, particularly concerns about how
others may evaluate one's body, are a particular area that requires further
research. The results of the present research also demonstrated the
importance of investigating the effects of body image separately for men and
women and for different age groups. This is the first study to demonstrate
that body image may play different roles in the lives of different adult
populations. Replication of these findings is required, particularly in
longitudinal research, in order to explore potential underlying mechanisms
to explain the role of body image in the psychological, social, and sexual
functioning of men and women at different stages of adult development. The
current sample was divided into three broad age categories, on the basis of
sample size. Future researchers exploring the development of body image in
adulthood should consider theoretically developed stages of adult
development when selecting appropriate age categories to investigate. For
example, body image may play a different role in the lives of adults 50-65
years than for adults in later years. Smaller, more homogeneous groups may
demonstrate differences in the development of body image and highlight
specific associations of body image and day-to-day functioning at different
ages.
This study was limited by the use of correlational data.
Small sample sizes in each group precluded the use of more sophisticated
techniques, such as structural equation modeling, which may be employed in
future research with larger samples to model relationships between body
image and psychological, social, and sexual functioning variables. An
investigation of these relationships was beyond the scope of this article,
and they were not accounted for in the present analysis, which was focused
on understanding which specific aspects of body image were of most relevance
to particular aspects of day-to-day functioning. Future researchers may
gainfully model the nature of the relationships between different aspects of
body image for different populations. It is hoped that increased
acknowledgement of the complexity of the body image construct, particularly
in relation to the varied roles it plays in the lives of adult men and
women, will stimulate further theoretical and empirical development in this
area.
|
Table I. Height, Weight, and BMI by Gender and Age
Group |
|
Height (cm) |
Weight (kg) |
Body mass index (BMI) |
| Age Group |
M |
SD |
M |
SD |
M |
SD |
| Women |
| 18-29 |
165.24 |
7.26 |
63.08 |
12.01 |
23.24 |
4.35 |
| 30-49 |
164.28 |
7.42 |
71.32 |
17.28 |
26.43 |
6.23 |
| 50-86 |
162.54 |
7.56 |
69.72 |
13.29 |
26.46 |
5.22 |
| Overall |
164.00 |
7.44 |
68.63 |
15.13 |
25.60 |
5.63 |
| Men |
| 18-29 |
179.68 |
8.03 |
74.87 |
12.48 |
23.18 |
3.55 |
| 30-49 |
180.45 |
7.22 |
83.72 |
14.14 |
25.75 |
3.84 |
| 50-86 |
175.69 |
7.66 |
82.26 |
12.66 |
26.65 |
3.30 |
| Overall |
178.34 |
7.87 |
79.84 |
13.56 |
25.13 |
3.86 |
|
Table II. Body Image Scores by Gender and Age Group |
|
Physical attractiveness |
Body image satisfaction |
| Group |
M |
SD |
M |
SD |
| Gender |
| Women |
18.57 |
3.51 |
31.23 |
8.56 |
| Men |
18.51 |
3.57 |
35.46 |
7.21 |
| Age |
|
| 18-29 |
19.80 |
3.68 |
33.41 |
7.56 |
| 30-49 |
18.11 |
3.49 |
31.73 |
8.82 |
| 50-86 |
18.00 |
3.24 |
34.80 |
7.95 |
|
Body Image Importance |
Body concealment |
| Group |
M |
SD |
M |
SD |
| Gender |
| Women |
32.00 |
7.44 |
15.40 |
5.72 |
| Men |
30.94 |
7.61 |
9.77 |
4.73 |
| Age |
| 18-29 |
30.83 |
7.93 |
12.12 |
5.12 |
| 30-49 |
31.60 |
7.03 |
14.07 |
6.39 |
| 50-86 |
31.93 |
7.77 |
11.91 |
6.07 |
|
Body improvement |
Social physique anxiety |
| Group |
M |
SD |
M |
SD |
| Gender |
| Women |
9.22 |
3.74 |
34.50 |
9.46 |
| Men |
8.70 |
3.70 |
27.68 |
8.11 |
| Age |
| 18-29 |
9.40 |
3.41 |
32.47 |
9.27 |
| 30-49 |
9.05 |
3.38 |
32.92 |
9.95 |
| 50-86 |
8.62 |
3.45 |
28.25 |
8.45 |
|
Appearance comparison |
| Group |
M |
SD |
| Gender |
| Women |
10.98 |
3.29 |
| Men |
9.17 |
3.35 |
| Age |
| 18-29 |
11.00 |
3.48 |
| 30-49 |
10.64 |
3.25 |
| 50-86 |
8.76 |
3.18 |
| Table III.
Unique Body Image Predictors From Regression Equations That
Significantly Increased the Prediction of Psychological Functioning
at Step 2 Among Men and Women of Different Age Groups |
| Unique body |
| Outcome variable |
Group |
image predictors |
[sr.sup.2] |
| Self-esteem |
Women 18-29 |
None |
-- |
|
Women 30-49 |
Social physique anxiety |
.06 |
|
Body Image Importance |
.05 |
|
Women 50-86 |
Physical attractiveness |
.13 |
|
Men 18-29 |
Physical attractiveness |
.07 |
Body image
importance |
.07 |
|
Men 30-49 |
Body concealment |
.10 |
|
Men 50-86 |
Appearance comparison |
.08 |
|
Body image satisfaction |
.07 |
| Depression |
Women 50-86 |
Social physique anxiety |
.08 |
| Anxiety |
Women 50-86 |
None |
-- |
|
Men 50-86 |
Appearance comparison |
.11 |
|
Table IV. Unique Body Image Predictors From
Regression Equations That Significantly Increased the Prediction of
Social and Sexual Functioning at Step 2 Among Men and Women of
Different Age Groups |
|
Unique body |
| Outcome variable |
Group |
image predictors |
[sr.sup.2] |
| Social anxiety |
Women 50-86 |
Social physique anxiety |
.08 |
| Body improvement |
.07 |
| Men 30-49 |
Appearance comparison |
.08 |
| Same-sex relations |
Men 30-49 |
Physical attractiveness |
.13 |
| Opposite-sex relations |
Men 18-29 |
Body concealment |
.09 |
| Sexual self-efficacy |
Men 30-49 |
Body satisfaction |
.09 |
| Sexual satisfaction |
Men 30-49 |
Appearance comparison |
.12 |
| Body concealment |
.10 |
|
Body satisfaction |
.08 |
| Sexual optimism |
Women 30-49 |
None |
-- |
|
Men 30-49 |
Social physique anxiety |
.18 |
Sources
top ~
pages: 1 2
3 4
5 6
7 ~
send page to a
friend
|